Skip to main content
Close Button
Donate
  • Replies 20 replies
  • Subscribers 41 subscribers
  • Views 808 views
  • Users 0 members are here
Options
Related
Hints and tips
  • To quote someone's message, first select/highlight the relevant text, and then use the Quote button that appears
  • To "mention" someone, type @ followed by the start of the forum name, and choose from the list; that person will get a notification of being mentioned

Defence Lawyers using defence of ASD for offenders that commit serious crime.

Craig
15 days ago

I have noticed an increase in the media and defence lawyers using ASD as an excuse for those offenders that commit the most serious of crimes.

I feel the only mental health defence that is permittable is when you are deemed by law to be Criminally Insane.

It really pisses me off when the media say the preprtator is a LONER or has ASD.

I am a loner and have been all my life and recently diagnosed as Austistic, I still knew right from wrong.

I think its offensive to tag ASD to these criminals as us all get tarred with the same brush and people will worry if we are potential killers because of our ASD.

What are your thoughts? Could the NAS not contact the media and tell them to stop saying the preprtator is on the spectrum or ASD?.

Parents
  • 14 days ago

    Thank you all for your replies, I get that this is a very emotive subject, as I am only recently diagnosed, I've always saw things as BLACK & WHITE, no middle ground and I am trying to see other viewpoints and it's extremely difficult for me.

    In saying that, I do wish the media would stop saying things "He/She is autistic and so on". I fear this could lead to people fearing that they are autistic and afraid to tell others that they are for fear of being judged because of the few that commit deplorable acts.

Reply
  • 14 days ago

    Thank you all for your replies, I get that this is a very emotive subject, as I am only recently diagnosed, I've always saw things as BLACK & WHITE, no middle ground and I am trying to see other viewpoints and it's extremely difficult for me.

    In saying that, I do wish the media would stop saying things "He/She is autistic and so on". I fear this could lead to people fearing that they are autistic and afraid to tell others that they are for fear of being judged because of the few that commit deplorable acts.

Children
  • 9 days ago in reply to Craig

    Not just the mainstream media but also social media stuff too like crime hunting groups who post videos on youtube seem to luke showing people with disabilities who have done some terrible things but they like to victimised whole groups of people for the actions  of the few 

  • 9 days ago in reply to Craig

    Same here, it's something I've struggled with, think there may be grey areas!

    The press seem to use all sorts of generalisations to wind people up, since this thread started I saw a news article "driver of BMW kills pedestrian" like all BMW drivers are somehow a category of their own!

    Can't help but think it's all part of a strategy employed to sensationalise things, all lined up  to someone's agenda.

  • 13 days ago in reply to Craig

    I agree, my ASD has manifested as an incredibly strong sense of morality though I've moderated it by introducing a concept of whether an immoral (wrong) act justifies guilt or punishment based on the intent (generally judged by non-maleficence standards). A simplistic example being that killing is morally wrong, but no one should punish a soldier for acting to protect others.


    With that said, the way that ASD is used in court varies greatly and I think a lot gets lost in the media reports but I do share the concern that by trying to use it as a defence can alienate people, particularly when it's done without context about how that particular person manifests their symptoms.