Bad manners and good manners in sickness and in health

Our 13 year old son was recently diagnosed with aspergers. He has all the classic problems with socialising and social communications, but is academically sound. We have not told him about his condition yet. Most of the time he does not use good manners, despite our constant reminders - he very rarely says please and thankyou and generally shows little empathy or respect. BUT whenever he is ill, even with just a cold, he becomes a different child. He is impeccably polite, well mannered and thoughtful. When he gets better he reverts to his normal self. Has anyone else experienced this? Should I be encouraged that deep down he does know how to behave properly, or discouraged because his 'normal' self rejects this?

thank you

Parents
  • Not silly at all longman. I hadn't thought of it that way round. His 'ill-self' does seem natural and real, so maybe the stresses of everday 'healthy' life are what causes him to slip into a defensive rudeness. He has never been in trouble at school for this sort of thing, and probably does save it all for us at home. I haven't noticed any improvements at weekends or on holiday, so it's a bit more than school I think. But you have got me to look at the problem in a different way.

    Many thanks

Reply
  • Not silly at all longman. I hadn't thought of it that way round. His 'ill-self' does seem natural and real, so maybe the stresses of everday 'healthy' life are what causes him to slip into a defensive rudeness. He has never been in trouble at school for this sort of thing, and probably does save it all for us at home. I haven't noticed any improvements at weekends or on holiday, so it's a bit more than school I think. But you have got me to look at the problem in a different way.

    Many thanks

Children
No Data