There once was an Ugly Duckling

It's feathers all dirty and brown.. and in so many words the other birds said quack get out of town,

But when spring comes and the "ugly duckling" becomes a swan all of a sudden all the other birds want to be friends.

This childrens song has always upset me, even from a small child, almost reducing me to tears at times. I felt so sorry fo the cygnet who was outcast and rejected for being ugly and brown. As an adult this song still upsets me, I don't just feel sorry for the cygnet but outraged and the implicit racism of being "ugly and brown" rather than beautiful and white as it later becomes. But at the way the other birds stop bullying it and want to be friends, I almost feel this is reflection of so many peoples struggles about being different and how others are encouraged through this song that it's OK to bully others who don't look the same as you or come across the same as you. It's only when the cygnet becomes a beautiful white swan that it's socially acceptable, what does that imply about those of us who are "ugly and brown"? Do we have to become white, do we have to transform ourselves entirely to be acceptable? To me this is a metaphor for not just racism, but for anyone who's different.

Parents
  • I dont really take it as racism I dont know when the rhyme was originally created but I imagine it was more a metaphor on beauty rather than racism, I guess you could say its about how life is built on luck and you can become a "valuable" member of society, or if you one of the people who never become "beautiful" you can see the shallowness of society that people will change how they see you as a person, not based on your character but on the way they perceive you, I can see why you remember the rhyme its actually quite relevant to people like us.

  • I think your right there, I've never been keen on it, as it always seemed to say that you can only be accepted in society if you make yourself beautiful. Plus I could identify as the cygnet for being bullied and not belonging.

    And I thought the song was annoying as the catchy chorus was 

    'quack, get out of,

    quack, get out of,

    quack, get out of town'. 

    Unfortunately it's now looping round my head! (We had 3 cassette tapes of children's rhymes and songs -they had covers you could line them up in a row and they got together).

  • yeah its one of those stories that seem nice as a child but shows a bit more when you get older, especially if you kinda just stay and dont become a swan, 

    haha did the cassettes line up to make a picture of a swan?

Reply Children
No Data