what’s the best place to get a autism diagnosis test? Not everywhere is the same. Is there any better places to go in Scotland as it costs a out of money
what’s the best place to get a autism diagnosis test? Not everywhere is the same. Is there any better places to go in Scotland as it costs a out of money
This isn’t a hard rule, it states where available. Usually children get this or any other NHS assessment (if you don’t retire before you get seen). NHS is based around MDT.
A single experienced consultant psychiatrist (or clinical psychologist) who:
this is sufficient, valid, fits NICE criteria and is 99% of private assessments. Mine was done by a leading psychiatrist in the field at NHS South London and Maudsley which are also home to some of the top consultants in the world, but also sees people privately. It was accepted by my GP and is my medical record. I don’t want people thinking if it’s not MDT led then it’s invalid as that’s not the case. Your comment infers that, at least that’s what I taken from it.
The ‘gold standard’ according to NICE guidelines is for the assessment to be conducted by a multi disciplinary team of appropriate professionals. This is shown in the link you have provided and I have copied the relevant section.
In my area, the GPs accepted private diagnosis only if the assessment was conducted according to these guidelines.
Here is a section of the NICE guidelines from the link you provided:
In order to effectively provide care and support for autistic adults, the local autism multi-agency strategy group should include representation from managers, commissioners and clinicians from adult services, including mental health, learning disability, primary healthcare, social care, housing, educational and employment services, the criminal justice system and the third sector. There should be meaningful representation from autistic people and their families, partners and carers.
In each area a specialist community-based multidisciplinary team for autistic adults (the specialist autism team) should be established. The membership should include:
psychologists with training and experience in working with autistic adults
nurses
occupational therapists
psychiatrists
social workers
speech and language therapists
support staff (for example, staff supporting access to housing, educational and employment services, financial advice, and personal and community safety skills).
The specialist autism team should have a key role in the delivery and coordination of:
specialist diagnostic and assessment services
specialist care and interventions
advice and training to other health and social care professionals on the diagnosis, assessment, care and interventions for autistic adults (as not all may be in the care of a specialist team)
support in accessing, and maintaining contact with, housing, educational and employment services
support to families, partners and carers where appropriate
care and interventions for autistic adults living in specialist residential accommodation
training, support and consultation for staff who care for autistic adults in residential and community settings.
I don’t know if GPs are individually allowed to choose what they will accept, or if it comes from higher up within each individual country.
I wondered that too.
my GP and the NHS Adult Autism Service would accept diagnosis only if undertaken by a multidisciplinary team.
I have had my diagnosis accepted by my GP but then it was a private provider via the NHS.
I am wondering whether the fact that I live in England, you in Northern Ireland and JB33 in Scotland makes the difference with regard to what GPs will accept.
I understand it to be if not MDT led than your diagnosis is not valid? Is that your point?
You misunderstand what I am saying. I have not suggested that your diagnosis was invalid.
My personal opinion is one thing, it isn’t claiming to be anything else. I will explain as best I can. If I wasn’t already diagnosed, I would seek a clinic that offered assessment by a multidisciplinary team. NICE guidelines are based on best evidence, so it makes sense to me to take their advice. Best evidence doesn’t mean that multidisciplinary teams are necessarily always the best way to go about something. Available evidence is weighed in favour of a multidisciplinary team assessment, so it makes sense to me to go down that route.
As I’ve already said in my previous post, my GP and the NHS Adult Autism Service in my area would accept diagnosis only if undertaken by a multidisciplinary team.
glad you finally got your diagnosis too; I absolutely would not doubt it. Mine was a single psychiatrist and he was more than qualified too. What some people dont recognise is that the people that run some of the private assessments are usually NHS consultants too. Mine was online as well, but again, doesn't deter from the validity of the diagnosis as that comes down to the methods and assessments used and that these are inline with NICE guidelines and recommendations (which many are). I would approach your GP, have them key it into your medical record as this will also not be keyed in lightly and will be scrutinised, as it should be, but once it's in, its valid. The doubt I think comes from scam online claims that you can be assessed and seen in 30 minutes kind of thing and that they do not follow the DSM-5/ICD-11 and other rigid guidelines required to make a formal diagnosis.
What some also dont see is that while NHS assessments are often MDT led, lack of resources can mean that the lead clinician owns the diagnosis and is often made by one consultant. If your diagnosis letter outlines the criteria used to diagnose you and your GP / medical system accepts this on your record, then that's all there is to it. Best of luck :)
I understand it to be if not MDT led than your diagnosis is not valid?
Welcome to the forum.
I obviously can't answer for A but I've learned from being on this forum that there is quite a variety in autism diagnosis methods.
Mine was online and via only 2 people - one consultant psychiatrist and one psychologist.
I had lots of forms too.
From reading here, I have at times doubted my own diagnosis as not being thorough enough (especially because it wasn't in person) but I've also read of lots of people who had a single psychiatrist diagnose them and that is sufficient to have the NHS records updated which should be good enough for everyone.
I'm glad you got yours - mine was much later in life.
It makes a huge difference, I've found.
I’m not sure what you’re getting at here? I don’t know how to take this? And I’m struggling to get to the root argument you have and what you’re trying to say (without all the words going around it). I understand it to be if not MDT led than your diagnosis is not valid? Is that your point? I think it is , you just won’t say it. Also, you really like to quote certain parts out of context and somehow draft it as factual and miss the other detail out. This is not helpful.
Regardless - I’m wasting energy now. Let’s agree to disagree. For the benefit of everyone here who may now be concerned about their diagnosis thanks to this forum member, I have asked my psychiatrist to write a summary around this - he will gladly do so and I’ll be posting the response here for clarity.
The section 1.2.5 A details “should” for each of the recommendations you quote above
Indeed.
Yes. Good spot on that Iain, I think it’s because there are some suspect assessments out there and not all are from qualified doctors who specialise in this area with the right credentials.
it is absolutely important people do their research first before paying privately to ensure these are ideally the same clinicians who work in the NHS or are equally as qualified.
Yes. Good spot on that Iain, I think it’s because there are some suspect assessments out there and not all are from qualified doctors who specialise in this area with the right credentials.
it is absolutely important people do their research first before paying privately to ensure these are ideally the same clinicians who work in the NHS or are equally as qualified.
