The problem in Scotland is that most governmental functions are managed by semi-independent bodies, to whom MSPs refer issues.
The quality of output from some of these bodies is misleading, often protective of the professions or other interested parties within that organisation.
Sound familiar? Well its basically the same as the Civil Service, except the bodies in question are more independent and self governing. In England, if you ask a question of an MP, the MP will ask that part of the Civil Service, who will write back to the MP in a form the MP can pass to a constituent.
In Scotland the advisory body will write direct to the enquirer leaving out the MSP.
This lends itself to extraordinary levels of abuse and corruption. Which is going to a big worry if there's a yes vote in the coming referendum.
There isn't remotely enough central accountability.
The problem in Scotland is that most governmental functions are managed by semi-independent bodies, to whom MSPs refer issues.
The quality of output from some of these bodies is misleading, often protective of the professions or other interested parties within that organisation.
Sound familiar? Well its basically the same as the Civil Service, except the bodies in question are more independent and self governing. In England, if you ask a question of an MP, the MP will ask that part of the Civil Service, who will write back to the MP in a form the MP can pass to a constituent.
In Scotland the advisory body will write direct to the enquirer leaving out the MSP.
This lends itself to extraordinary levels of abuse and corruption. Which is going to a big worry if there's a yes vote in the coming referendum.
There isn't remotely enough central accountability.