Autism or neglect?

I'm becoming increasingly concerned about a young boy I know, he's ten years old and homeschooled. His mother has self diagnosed autism and uses it to excuse his behaviour and his lack of development.

He can verbally communicate like any other 10 year old, understands instructions, can play games requiring rules etc he can control a pen to draw. He plays computer games like minecraft. He walks and runs perfectly well. Plays tennis and swims etc

However, he can't read (at all), he can't write or spell. He still goes in a pushchair. I know from conversations with other parents who know them that his mother still takes him to the bathroom, she bathes him and they share a bed. Whenever I've seen him have a tantrum, she starts panicking saying things like "okay okay we don't have to do that". He freaks out if his needs aren't met instantly, she has several bags with her always, containing spare clothes, medi kit, food, drinks, activities, blanket etc. He tends to ignore adults, but talks fine with other children. The mum has said to another mum she prefers him to have younger friends cause she doesn't want him to grow up too fast. She says she prefers unschooling, and doesn't ever make him do work.

It's very odd, and I fear she's using autism to cover up the fact she's failed to teach him how to read and write. She does everything she can to prevent tantrums, she panders to his behaviour. If he doesn't want to do something, he doesn't do it simple.o

I don't know, I'm wondering if parents of actual diagnosed children feel like this is familiar or if something is off. Does this sound like autism or neglect

Parents
  • His mother has self diagnosed autism and uses it to excuse his behaviour and his lack of development.

    I mean I thought diagnosis for children was fairly easy to access so I don't know why you'd feel forced to self diagnose at that age. Thats the only part of this I really find odd.

    He can verbally communicate like any other 10 year old, understands instructions, can play games requiring rules etc he can control a pen to draw. He plays computer games like minecraft. He walks and runs perfectly well. Plays tennis and swims etc

    How's that relivent? Autism has nothing to do with academic capability must less athletics. I think you're confusing autism with intellectual disability.

    However, he can't read (at all), he can't write or spell.

    So possibly serious dislexia? It isn't uncommon to find people with issues like dislexia along aside autism.

    He still goes in a pushchair. I know from conversations with other parents who know them that his mother still takes him to the bathroom, she bathes him and they share a bed. Whenever I've seen him have a tantrum, she starts panicking saying things like "okay okay we don't have to do that". He freaks out if his needs aren't met instantly, she has several bags with her always, containing spare clothes, medi kit, food, drinks, activities, blanket etc.

    Some of that could be an indication of PDA type fetures. Eg he's not in the pushchair because he needs to be but because he's used to it and resists change (for example with tantrums). That's not so rare in autism.

    It's very odd, and I fear she's using autism to cover up the fact she's failed to teach him how to read and write. She does everything she can to prevent tantrums, she panders to his behaviour. If he doesn't want to do something, he doesn't do it simple.

    The so called tough love approach to autistic children tantrums can sometimes make things much much worse. However if you truly believe the child isn't being educated you could write a letter to the local education authority (usually the council or a body the council sets up to do the job for them). However I doubt they'll be particularly concerned if it merely turns out the parent in this case is simply adopting a very liberal approach to educating a child with special needs. The law only says children need to be educated not that they need to be educated in a particular way. Homeschoolers are free to depart from the national curriculum and normal means of school disaplin so long as their children are learning.

Reply
  • His mother has self diagnosed autism and uses it to excuse his behaviour and his lack of development.

    I mean I thought diagnosis for children was fairly easy to access so I don't know why you'd feel forced to self diagnose at that age. Thats the only part of this I really find odd.

    He can verbally communicate like any other 10 year old, understands instructions, can play games requiring rules etc he can control a pen to draw. He plays computer games like minecraft. He walks and runs perfectly well. Plays tennis and swims etc

    How's that relivent? Autism has nothing to do with academic capability must less athletics. I think you're confusing autism with intellectual disability.

    However, he can't read (at all), he can't write or spell.

    So possibly serious dislexia? It isn't uncommon to find people with issues like dislexia along aside autism.

    He still goes in a pushchair. I know from conversations with other parents who know them that his mother still takes him to the bathroom, she bathes him and they share a bed. Whenever I've seen him have a tantrum, she starts panicking saying things like "okay okay we don't have to do that". He freaks out if his needs aren't met instantly, she has several bags with her always, containing spare clothes, medi kit, food, drinks, activities, blanket etc.

    Some of that could be an indication of PDA type fetures. Eg he's not in the pushchair because he needs to be but because he's used to it and resists change (for example with tantrums). That's not so rare in autism.

    It's very odd, and I fear she's using autism to cover up the fact she's failed to teach him how to read and write. She does everything she can to prevent tantrums, she panders to his behaviour. If he doesn't want to do something, he doesn't do it simple.

    The so called tough love approach to autistic children tantrums can sometimes make things much much worse. However if you truly believe the child isn't being educated you could write a letter to the local education authority (usually the council or a body the council sets up to do the job for them). However I doubt they'll be particularly concerned if it merely turns out the parent in this case is simply adopting a very liberal approach to educating a child with special needs. The law only says children need to be educated not that they need to be educated in a particular way. Homeschoolers are free to depart from the national curriculum and normal means of school disaplin so long as their children are learning.

Children
No Data