• Replies 6 replies
  • Subscribers 28 subscribers
  • Views 3923 views
  • Users 0 members are here
Options
Related
Hints and tips
  • To quote someone's message, first select/highlight the relevant text, and then use the Quote button that appears
  • To "mention" someone, type @ followed by the start of the forum name, and choose from the list; that person will get a notification of being mentioned

Are American books and websites about social skills relevant in Britain?

Arran

I don’t think that anybody can keep count of the number of books and websites about social skills – and the number keeps on increasing as each day goes by - but why is it that something close to 99% of those written in English are American? It’s probably safe to assume that they are intended to be read by Americans or immigrants to the US, rather than people who live in other English speaking countries. Social skills books and websites that are British, from another English speaking country, from a country where English is a strong second language (such as India), or translations of material published in foreign languages are rare in comparison.

Is the reason why Americans have a near monopoly on English language social skills books and websites a result of faults and failures of the American education system? Surely if kids learn social skills at school (and learning social skills is high on the list of reasons of pro-school types why kids should attend school rather than home education) then there would be little need for social skills books and websites for adults. If the American education system is not to blame, or is no less effective as a facility to learn social skills than schools in the rest of the world, then what is the explanation why Americans have written the number of social skills books and websites as they have done?

Have a significant number of social skills books and websites been written in a language other than English for use in countries where English is not the main or official language, or are they a peculiarly English language phenomenon?

Are American social skills books and websites relevant, or even desirable, for British people to learn social skills for British society, or are they misleading and largely irrelevant due to differences between British and American culture and social expectations?

Have any American social skills books and websites been evaluated and recommended for their relevance and effectiveness for children and adults with Asperger syndrome or other autistic spectrum disorders who live in Britain?

Parents

  • Geoark said:
    Population of UK, Canada and Australia in 2013 totalled 122.39 million

    Population of US in 2014 318.9 million

    For UK, Canada and Australia the UK had 64.1 milliion, over half the total despite having a much lower landmass.

    It is not really surprising that much of the literature available is American.

    The quantity of published material from each English speaking country is not roughly proportional to the population of the country. Close to 99% is American.

    The other thing to consider is that there is not a single culture within Britain, rather a mixture of cultures within British Society, each with their own rules and behavioural norms. This applies even more so to US Society.

    I have thought of this. Is it possible that both countries have federal and local cultures but the books and websites primarily address federal American culture, or are biased towards a particular local culture - I make an intelligence guess of California or the east coast?

    As to their relevance most of the strategies for improving social skills for autism were initially developed in the US.

    Many of the books and websites are not autism specific or only give a brief passing mention of ASD.

    I would be more concerned if you were talking about American literature on how to get on in business. I was speaking to someone who had spent money on Business Gurus and did what he was told for it to backfire. I asked him if they were American and tried to explain in the circumstances he explained why their advice did not work for the situation he described.

    An interesting story. A high proportion of business books are also American and may contain significant material that is not applicable outside of the US.

Reply

  • Geoark said:
    Population of UK, Canada and Australia in 2013 totalled 122.39 million

    Population of US in 2014 318.9 million

    For UK, Canada and Australia the UK had 64.1 milliion, over half the total despite having a much lower landmass.

    It is not really surprising that much of the literature available is American.

    The quantity of published material from each English speaking country is not roughly proportional to the population of the country. Close to 99% is American.

    The other thing to consider is that there is not a single culture within Britain, rather a mixture of cultures within British Society, each with their own rules and behavioural norms. This applies even more so to US Society.

    I have thought of this. Is it possible that both countries have federal and local cultures but the books and websites primarily address federal American culture, or are biased towards a particular local culture - I make an intelligence guess of California or the east coast?

    As to their relevance most of the strategies for improving social skills for autism were initially developed in the US.

    Many of the books and websites are not autism specific or only give a brief passing mention of ASD.

    I would be more concerned if you were talking about American literature on how to get on in business. I was speaking to someone who had spent money on Business Gurus and did what he was told for it to backfire. I asked him if they were American and tried to explain in the circumstances he explained why their advice did not work for the situation he described.

    An interesting story. A high proportion of business books are also American and may contain significant material that is not applicable outside of the US.

Children
No Data