New Simpsons episode about nuerodivergent characters. Anyone watch it?

Recently saw one of the newer Simpsons episodes, "Testing 1-2-3", had pretty mixed opinions on it, tbh.

Seymour Skinner being on the spectrum felt like a kind of forced recontextualization. Classic humorus traits of his rigidity and lack of nueroplasticity were now attributed to autism. Homer having ADHD is a little questionable, too, mostly because having ADHD often implies intelligence, which most certainly contradicts everyone's favourite donut loving nuclear safety inspector. Comic Book Guy having OCD fits him well, though.

That being said, the message of the episode did make me smile.

Parents
  • Ive not watched it but I'll check it out.

    I can see Seymour being autistic to be fair.

    I am a little confused about your suggestion that ADHD suggests intelligence. There is no link between ADHD and intelligence. Some people with ADHD are very academic, others having learning difficulties. I'm not sure I'd particularly have thought of Homer as having ADHD before now but there are different presentations of ADHD, Bart being the stereotypical presentation they have visited before. But ADHD can also be inattentive meaning people are forgetful, disorganised, easily distracted, day dreamy and when you write it down like that, Homer probably ticks every box.

    I'd have to watch it to comment on the OCD part. OCD is very often misrepresented and can be debilitating so it depends how they showed that for me.

    I think it is good to have representation of different conditions in shows and certainly in a town like Springfield, there would be a number of neurodivergent people. I think you could easily diagnose a few more from watching the show. But I do also think it's important it doesn't get over done. I will come back and give more thoughts when I've had a chance to watch it.

  • Having now watched it. On the whole I liked it. Yes it was over simplified and over the top but it is a comedy show and I think they presented it pretty well. I liked that they weren't sterotypical presentations of the conditions and showed that people with them can hold down jobs etc.

    The assessment part was a little bit bizarre with the way they showed it but it is just a cartoon kids show so not that bigger deal.

    It lost me towards the end when they started singing about everyone having a bit and making it look like every character was neurodivergent. They should have made it clear that not everyone is neurodivergent and having traits does not mean you need a diagnosis.

  • No the bit I could do. Without is comic book guy and his wife enabling eachothers OCD rituals 

  • I understand all that. I wasn't suggesting you wouldn't try to treat the OCD. But not being allowed to do a ritual can cause significantly more distress to an individual than doing it. Which is why I said the underlying issues that are causing the OCD need to be treated. Not just trying to restrict rituals.

  • As someone who's lived with people and has to dela with with people with ocd in yn family a lot even the harmless things can harm others for example not wanting to go to a cettian place may not cause them. Harm but when it becomes. No one can go there that causes. Distress for others 

    Turning. The tv off because you got triggered by a mention of dirt or something it may seem harmles but can fry the insides of the tv slowly etc 

    The rituals may not always cause physical hsrm but can cause ditress to. friends and family... I mean imagine being autistic and relying on being punctual but a ocd friend or relative has to turn the door knob 34 times and check the taps 7 times you would be in distress as much as they are 

  • I'm really surprised by this. I actually thought that all of the portrayals moved away from the stereotypes. Yes it was all over the top but I'd expect that with comedy. It's very disappointing to hear they didn't research it though. That's very poor.

  • The Simpsons of all programs has enough clout behind it that experts would be perfectly willing to contribute to the research required to diagnose and portray certain characters as being nuerodivergent.

    Would they be laughing at us and is that a good thing?

    But would the characters be as funny as they want? The appeal to the masses is what dictates what gets into the episodes so it may be a good thing not to have neurodivergent characters being the subject or this style of humour.

  • Having watched a video essay about the episode, it turns out that the writers didn't even bother to do research on the conditions they were portraying and were just going by common stereotypes. If this was something else, then fair enough, but I'm sure The Simpsons of all programs has enough clout behind it that experts would be perfectly willing to contribute to the research required to diagnose and portray certain characters as being nuerodivergent.

    On the other hand, turns out many with ADHD actually identify with Homer, but at the same time found this episode blew those traits out of proportion

  • I get where you're coming from but I'm not sure that's entirely accurate. I am not an expert but that does not fit in with the training on OCD that I have done. The advice was very much if the ritual isn't causing great harm or distress to them or others to leave it alone. Therapy work would be done to try to help with the greater issue so they hopefully wouldn't feel the need to do the rituals anymore.

Reply
  • I get where you're coming from but I'm not sure that's entirely accurate. I am not an expert but that does not fit in with the training on OCD that I have done. The advice was very much if the ritual isn't causing great harm or distress to them or others to leave it alone. Therapy work would be done to try to help with the greater issue so they hopefully wouldn't feel the need to do the rituals anymore.

Children
  • I understand all that. I wasn't suggesting you wouldn't try to treat the OCD. But not being allowed to do a ritual can cause significantly more distress to an individual than doing it. Which is why I said the underlying issues that are causing the OCD need to be treated. Not just trying to restrict rituals.

  • As someone who's lived with people and has to dela with with people with ocd in yn family a lot even the harmless things can harm others for example not wanting to go to a cettian place may not cause them. Harm but when it becomes. No one can go there that causes. Distress for others 

    Turning. The tv off because you got triggered by a mention of dirt or something it may seem harmles but can fry the insides of the tv slowly etc 

    The rituals may not always cause physical hsrm but can cause ditress to. friends and family... I mean imagine being autistic and relying on being punctual but a ocd friend or relative has to turn the door knob 34 times and check the taps 7 times you would be in distress as much as they are 

  • I'm really surprised by this. I actually thought that all of the portrayals moved away from the stereotypes. Yes it was all over the top but I'd expect that with comedy. It's very disappointing to hear they didn't research it though. That's very poor.

  • The Simpsons of all programs has enough clout behind it that experts would be perfectly willing to contribute to the research required to diagnose and portray certain characters as being nuerodivergent.

    Would they be laughing at us and is that a good thing?

    But would the characters be as funny as they want? The appeal to the masses is what dictates what gets into the episodes so it may be a good thing not to have neurodivergent characters being the subject or this style of humour.

  • Having watched a video essay about the episode, it turns out that the writers didn't even bother to do research on the conditions they were portraying and were just going by common stereotypes. If this was something else, then fair enough, but I'm sure The Simpsons of all programs has enough clout behind it that experts would be perfectly willing to contribute to the research required to diagnose and portray certain characters as being nuerodivergent.

    On the other hand, turns out many with ADHD actually identify with Homer, but at the same time found this episode blew those traits out of proportion