Block Universe Theory

To first summarize as to what this theory is: at it's core, this theory suggests that time is not truly flowing but instead exists as a four-dimensional "block," with all past, present, and future moments equally real. This means that, much like how every point in space exists simultaneously, every point in time also exists simultaneously. Which is really quite disturbing! Essentially, the universe is a giant, unchanging structure where change is merely an illusion of our perception.

The implications of this theory are mind-bending: It challenges our sense of free will, as the future is already "written," and it suggests that every event—past or future—is as concrete as the present moment. It's often associated with Einstein's theory of relativity, which treats time as a dimension just like space.

Do you feel like the universe must have some room for spontaneity? :-)

Interestingly, if the block universe theory were indeed true (or rather real) it would mean that there is an universe in which Venus is ruled by sentient marmalade. (They have a troublingly disturbing addiction of really quite hastily consuming creosote).

Also, the block universe theory, while fascinating, isn't without its critics! (I thought it best to include some of them here just in case you found the theory to be really very disturbing and required some immediate evidence to disprove it!)

If the past, present, and future are all fixed within the "block," it suggests that free will is an illusion. Many philosophers and scientists argue that this deterministic view is incompatible with human experience, where choices seem real and significant.

The block universe is largely rooted in relativity, but quantum mechanics introduces uncertainty and probabilities that don’t neatly fit into a fixed timeline. The randomness inherent in quantum events suggests that the future may not be fully predetermined.

The theory doesn’t fully explain our perception of the "flow" of time. While physics treats time as another dimension, human consciousness experiences time as a dynamic progression rather than a static structure.

If all moments exist equally, what determines the experience of cause and effect? Some argue that the block universe struggles to account for why the past influences the future but not vice versa in practical experience.

The second law of thermodynamics states that entropy increases over time, implying a directionality to time. Critics argue that this natural progression contradicts the idea of a fully predetermined block structure.

In conclusion, some alternative theories attempt to preserve a more intuitive experience of time - very much like the growing block universe, where the past is fixed but the future remains open! Salutations! :-)

Parents
  • The theory doesn’t fully explain our perception of the "flow" of time

    It doesn’t explain the passage of time at all,  and that means I can’t get beyond that to engage in a serious argument.

    It might be an interesting philosophical exercise for some, and I expect it could lead to a discussion on the nature of free will, and to what extent we as human beings are determined by other’s actions.

  • Whilst I don't actively believe in this theory, I do find it to be really very interesting - if not slightly disturbing! :-)

Reply Children
  • Thanks Lotus. I’ll have a look at that. 

  • Hi Archaec, if you're interested in brain function and the differences between Autistic and NT minds, I'd recommend a book called "A field guide to Earthlings"  by Ian Ford

  • You have explained the arguments very clearly and they allowed me to reach my conclusion easily. I have never been able to get beyond the issue of ‘passage of time’ with many theories, but I like that you pose the question as I know it is of interest to people. 

    I recall posts on a similar topic on this forum a while back. Do you think that autistic people spend more time on this sort of thing than non autistic people? I don’t know anything about neuroscience but I would love to know and understand more about brain function.