I'm thinking of writting a book

A history book about all the things that we don't really know. Mostly it's because I've just read a book on the Picts and an now reading another by the same author on Aethelflaed, Lady of the Mercians, in both books there seem to be some rather large assumptons made unsupported by any evidence and lacking in any discussion about why the author has taken this position. I've come across this in a few books, it's somethng I'd expect more from much older books, but not from modern ones. I thought the days of being "told things" by historians was long gone, this particular author mentions all the advances made to the subjects he's writing about by geneticists and archaelogists how how they're changing our undstanding and then says he's not discussing them! 

There was another book by a different author, that seemed to ignore a whole swathe of material relevant to his subject matter, it had me shouting out loud, 'what about Freya?' and arguing with the book.

I think this will be a good excuse to expand my book collection and spend ridiculous amounts of money. I think I will buy myself a nice big and pretty note book for taking down notes and quotes, I think it's time I used my academic training for something, even if it will likely never be published and maybe not even finished, it will keep me amused and off the streets!

Parents
  • I'm sorry catwoman, but someone has to say this.  

    *sarc mode <on>*

    If you are going to be"writting a book" perhaps you ought to at least spell the title of it right!

    *sarc mode <off>* 

    Apart from that tiny detail, it seems you are possibly going to write something I'd like to read! 

Reply
  • I'm sorry catwoman, but someone has to say this.  

    *sarc mode <on>*

    If you are going to be"writting a book" perhaps you ought to at least spell the title of it right!

    *sarc mode <off>* 

    Apart from that tiny detail, it seems you are possibly going to write something I'd like to read! 

Children
  • Yes I will have to learn to use a spell checker and have all the hassle of learning how to use a word processor again and have it in UK English and grammar, rather than US English and grammar, it used to frustrate me so much that everytime there was an update word would switch back to its default US settings and change everything I'd written and I've have to go back and change it all again. It's left me with a Ggrrr feeling everytime a see a red wiggly. This is one reason why I won't type anything up until I have all my notes and everything and am ready to write.

    ****************************************************

    I do have a book of Celtic saints, but so little seems to be known about them that any biography is very short, mostly all that seems to be known is that they existed and roughly where they practiced. I do wonder if the sources have been deliberately ignored and lost, most of what we do have are later copies of original documents, and it can be quite difficult to know how accurate those copies are as scribes often left out or changed bits they didn't like. I wonder if this happened with early British Christianity, that it didn't survive because it didn't fit the narrative that the church was fostering. I suspect too that early British Christianity was similar to that Ireland and the Orthodox and Coptic churches. That would certainly fit in with the hermitages that seem so frequent in Britain and Ireland and the harsh living conditions of early monasteries, there was a lot of admiration and copying of the desert fathers.

    I wouldn't know where to begin with publication and I'd probaly be to afraid of rejection, but when It's done I might email it to people on request, so you will get to read it if you want to.