Electric or petrol cars

What's your thoughts?

Electric yay or nay?

I'm more of a petrol man myself.

Parents
  • Electric cars are undoubtedly better for the environment. However there are tons of problems with them in terms of practicality. At least if you’re the kind of guy who maybe once in a blue moon wants to drive 200 miles to an event and then 200 miles back in the evening because it’s something you really wanted to do; well with an electric car you can forget it. Not unless you have somewhere to park it that has a charger in the intervening period between the two trips.

    and it has to be a rapid charger not just an ordinary plug socket. Just plugging in at your house will take hours and hours to get a full charge.

    There was a very simple solution to this problem of a long amount of time it takes to charge your battery which was simply to make electric cars battery changeable. A lot of Electric cars already have a sales model where you rent the battery. it would’ve been a very easy thing to pass a law making it so that every electric cars battery needs to be easily removable and swappable with a generic standard. so instead of filling up with petrol at the pump you could have a machine lift your car off the ground (The batteries are usually mounted on the base of the car) swap out the battery with a pre charged one and pay a nominal fee for the difference in the electricity. Charged battery in five or 10 minutes instead of several hours

    but this would’ve required the government to a make Electric car batteries a government monopoly and make them responsible for putting in the infrastructure to do this.

    also a personal note I like driving a manual. I like having clutch control. Electric cars are all automatic. they could’ve at least done the courtesy of putting in a fake clutch that we could use for fine control and Station keeping when we want to move a car forwards or backwards a couple of inches precisely or make it hang on a hill without slamming on the break. It’s the way I’m used to controlling a car and I see no reason why they couldn’t of emulated that in an electric car system.

  • I would love to convert my Landy to electric but the cost is beyond me at present. I could keep the manual gearbox as well which as you mention, allows better control. As to range, we used to have something called Motor Rail where cars were loaded on to trains and drivers could sit in the carriages on the way to their destination. That could be one solution.   

  • What Landrover do you have? I've had a few. Three Discoveries, a Defender and an ex MOD but that was temporary for a friend. 

  • Nice they both sound great. I do like the old Landrovers, terrific cars brilliant off roaders as well. I don't have a landy currently but I'm hoping to get one again at some point.

  • Hello, I run a 1976 Series Three 88 2.25 diesel with an overdrive. I did own a  1986 3.5 V8 Range Rover for a while.    

Reply Children