That time of year...

Last year, after mum passed away, I told my brother that I wanted nothing to do with Christmas.  I'd never missed a Christmas Day with her, even though we'd lived apart for 25 years.  For the final 15 years of her life it was just the two of us on Christmas Day.  My brother always did things with his wife's family, who had really always been the focus of his attention since they married in 1984.  My decision last year was as much about my sister-in-law as anything.  Having put up with her narcissistic behaviour for all of those years, I decided that mum's passing was the time for me to break ties completely - for the good of my own health and sanity.  Her bullying behaviour had continued throughout the time I was caring for mum.  She even picked a fight with my brother's natural daughter on the day of the funeral - much against mum's express wishes for 'no squabbles'.  Anyway... I'd told my brother that 'no Christmas' meant I wouldn't be sending cards or buying gifts.  (We usually only gave token things at Christmas, anyway - and quite often, because neither he nor any of the rest of the family really 'knew' me, I would get stuff that would end up in the charity shops in January.  To me, the whole thing seemed such a waste.  Apart from the gifts I used to receive from mum, the other things had no real thought behind them.  It was just giving something for the sake of it.  Whereas I always used to spend a lot of time trying to choose something really appropriate for others.)  He didn't agree with my wishes, though - and insisted "You can do that if you like, as long as you respect our wish to carry on Christmas in the normal way."  Which meant he actually went against my wishes and sent me a card and a gift.  He made the excuse "We'd already bought the gifts in October."  But I'd told him of my wishes after the funeral, in May.

Anyway... that time is almost on us again.  And I don't know what to do.  I had a birthday card from my brother, and I sent one each to him and to his wife.  But I've had no other contact with either of them at all.  In fact, I've only seen my brother once since mum's birthday last year (November 21st - next week - I've taken the day off).  We all really might as well not exist to one another.  I thought I would send cards this year to all family.  But I won't send one to my brother's step-daughter, because - like her mother - her behaviour towards me was rude, arrogant and bullying, and she even started an argument over one of mum's carers on the night she passed away.  I want nothing at all to do with her any more.  Thing is... if I miss her out, it will register, and things will be said.  It could create a backlash.  The same with gifts.  I just don't feel like doing it - except for mum's great-grandchildren.  And they have everything, and more, so it'll probably be just gift tokens for them to spend as they wish.

It all seems trivial, but it isn't.  It's causing me a lot of grief.  It's that 'people-pleaser' thing.  I don't want to let anyone down - at the same time, I end up letting myself down.

Maybe I should just say 'no' to the whole thing again, and hang what they all think! 

I hate my head at times like this.

Parents
  • I certainly don't think that anyone should try to 'conform' to expectations over any particular festival. I think I only sent three cards last year and got three back.  And with postage the cost it is, I think there is a lot fewer Christmas cards being sent.   Certainly I wonder why anyone should give a card or present to a work colleague whom they see every day and are glad to see the back of in the evening.  And 'Secret Santa' is something I just can't be doing with.

    With todays multi-faith, diverse population with different beliefs and customs, it is surely not unacceptable for someone to say they do not wish to join in and they will celebrate or otherwise as they see fit.  I remember seeing a talk by a hill-walker years ago who went camping in the Lake District on Christmas day, and he showed pictures of his Christmas day - the site was full of tents in the snow!  Might not be everyone's cup of tea, but what concern is it really of anyone else?  And about ten years ago I thought I would go to Dovedale on Christmas day.  The car park was packed out.  So there are people who do not celebrate Christmas in a conventional way.

    I personally think the point of a card or gift is to show someone that you care about them. If you don't care about them then what is the point of the card or gift

    Myself I also only get gifts for my children, my brother, sister and mother.  And I would really like to call a truce to them as well and I think we are close to agreeing terms!

    I have a flat overflowing with presents from years past that I have not used or not opened.  And I feel that just giving a present that someone doesn't want in return for one that I don't want only really benefits businesses.  I certainly do not think anyone should get into debt over Christmas.  And if their reasons for giving a present are that they want to show appreciation, let them, I don't think presents should ever be given in expectation of something in return, that in my opinion is the worst possible motive.  If that is the motive, they will soon stop if you don't return the complement.

    The best present I could ever have from my children is a bit of time with them.  And that is something to be treasured far more than some frippery.  And in my heart I wish other people would think the same.

Reply
  • I certainly don't think that anyone should try to 'conform' to expectations over any particular festival. I think I only sent three cards last year and got three back.  And with postage the cost it is, I think there is a lot fewer Christmas cards being sent.   Certainly I wonder why anyone should give a card or present to a work colleague whom they see every day and are glad to see the back of in the evening.  And 'Secret Santa' is something I just can't be doing with.

    With todays multi-faith, diverse population with different beliefs and customs, it is surely not unacceptable for someone to say they do not wish to join in and they will celebrate or otherwise as they see fit.  I remember seeing a talk by a hill-walker years ago who went camping in the Lake District on Christmas day, and he showed pictures of his Christmas day - the site was full of tents in the snow!  Might not be everyone's cup of tea, but what concern is it really of anyone else?  And about ten years ago I thought I would go to Dovedale on Christmas day.  The car park was packed out.  So there are people who do not celebrate Christmas in a conventional way.

    I personally think the point of a card or gift is to show someone that you care about them. If you don't care about them then what is the point of the card or gift

    Myself I also only get gifts for my children, my brother, sister and mother.  And I would really like to call a truce to them as well and I think we are close to agreeing terms!

    I have a flat overflowing with presents from years past that I have not used or not opened.  And I feel that just giving a present that someone doesn't want in return for one that I don't want only really benefits businesses.  I certainly do not think anyone should get into debt over Christmas.  And if their reasons for giving a present are that they want to show appreciation, let them, I don't think presents should ever be given in expectation of something in return, that in my opinion is the worst possible motive.  If that is the motive, they will soon stop if you don't return the complement.

    The best present I could ever have from my children is a bit of time with them.  And that is something to be treasured far more than some frippery.  And in my heart I wish other people would think the same.

Children