Machines and engines

I've always loved machines and engines. 

I like a bit of nostalgia too. 

Here's a 1962 Twin Tub in action - I spent many happy hours in the company of a machine just like this as a child! 

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Mvs1aJ7ES60

Have you got a favourite machine or engine? 

  • If so, please share it! 
Parents
  • Former Member
    Former Member

    I'm keen on mechanical clocks and watches.  Many hours of amusement.

  • Pretty much my main mechanical fetish. I don't like anything that ticks though, sweeping hand, hand wound or automatic. Quartz is fine but only if the case is thick enough to hide the tick. The intricate nature of mechanicals is more interesting. German or Japanese mechanicals are best imo. 3 hand over chronograph too. I like field watches, divers, and of course fliegers. Swiss is good, but not at mid budget, generally. Not keen on anything with most ETA movements.

    I watched this earlier and found it awesome. I'm not a dress watch guy but I do have a thing for Lange and Söhne. I'll probably never own one but this was great. Attention to detail and finishing excellence.

    https://youtu.be/DGAsib-4mCk

  • Former Member
    Former Member in reply to Cloudy Mountains

    All mechanical movements "tick" - it's just a case of how noisy it is.  When you're setting a watch to rate the watch timing machine works by using a microphone to record the movement noise, and you adjust the rate of the watch by changing various things to get the different sounds the movement makes to occur at the right frequencies.  Clocks can be rated differently depending on the movement.

    For every day wear I prefer a nice simple face.  I  like the face style of the early "field watches" and "fligers" too, but I'd want a sapphire crystal in the back so I could watch them working :-).

    The thing is, for a "Swiss" watch, how much the watch costs bears very little resemblance to what movement it has in it.  And many of the "Swiss watches" have ETA movements. But you could find an ETA movement in a relatively inexpensive watch, but also the same ETA movement in a very much more expensive watch.  The ETA movements often go back to the earlier manufacturers who were  bought up by the Swatch group on the cheap when the Swiss watch industry was taking a battering from Japanese etc. Quartz and digital watches.

    I spent a year doing a watchmaking course part-time, and compared to Chinese knock-off versions of an ETA movement the ETA version was light years better quality and far easier to work with!

    I'm quite partial to some of the IWC, CWC, Laco watches.

  • Yeah, it did spring to mind. It could be a managable way of life. I gave up long ago about money, and I think that a modest living inside something I actually care about, plus can cope with is the way forward.

    That would be ideal, I'd imagine fixing Railmasters all day woukdn't be too sloppy!

  • Former Member
    Former Member in reply to Cloudy Mountains

    For someone with ASD, I don't think it's not a bad choice of career if you can live on the money.  Much of the time will be spent at the bench working on your own.  The guys I spoke to at the BHI said it was something you did because you loved it rather than for the money per-se.

    One of the guys at EFHC who had a few more years experience than me, plus he worked in the jewellery industry already IIRC, got sponsored by Omega I think to go to the British School of Watchmaking.

  • Thanks for the links Windscale. When or if my situation improves, it's something I've considered persuing. I've still got time, and a bit of knowledge beforehand, so it's certainly an option. I'd like to do high-end repairs, more than anything. I like restoring stuff.

    Looking at those Amazon links I see Breguet. Swatch swallowed that up too. I like pocket watches, but I'd only buy one as a collection piece. I'd like one of those really old Glashütte pocket watches. Germany had a pretty rich history of horology, predating the Swiss in a lot of aspects. The Nazi's and the Communists both destroyed Glashütte's industry, but since the wall fell, they have gone straight back to doing what they do best. It amazes me how what is essentially a village, has so many great watchmakers.

    Yeah, I like the Series Two probably best out of the Roger Smith pieces. It's great that Smith has started using tourbillons too, but that makes them more unobtainable, we can still look and drool though. Breguet has a lot to answer for, the invention of the tourbillon, and it's current surge in popularity puts some models way out of reach!

    I can't imagine they woukd have been Seagulls. Mind you I have seen a few nice models from Seagull. The 6497 was Unitas originally, but got sucked up into ETA. Nice movement to be looking at! Panerai have made some nice personal touches to the 6497, although it bumps up the price, and Panerai being on the dial does too! I find Panerai's designs a little brash and large. The largest watch I own is a 43mm case and that's because it's a shell case. I usually go around the 38mm to 40mm range. You've got me thinking about doing something like you did, it sounds pretty cool, and it could lead somewhere. 

  • Former Member
    Former Member in reply to Cloudy Mountains

    Have you ever regulated a watch to run at a totally different beat rate? Say 28800 BPH to run at a 21600 BPH? I'd imagine the wheels need to be changed to a different ratio. 

    Yes you're right, you'd have to redesign the going train to work at the different beat rate.  How much you'd have to change would depend on exactly what beat you were changing it to.

     I like the Hamilton Khaki Field mechanical that was recently released

    Yes I've looked at one of the Hamilton Khaki field watches that I quite liked but I don't recall what model it was.

    That's something I'd like to do myself. Must have been great!

    Yes, I'd like to do more, but I'm more interested in learning to design clocks/watches and then manufacture the parts.  Unfortunately we don't really have anywhere where we're currently living to house a load of machine tools :-(.  It's hard now in the UK to find anywhere to learn because the Horology industry has died so much.

    I went to Epping Forest Horology Centre: http://efhc.org.uk/wordpress/ and spent a year working with Lalit and others.

    The British Horological Institute run courses as well: https://bhi.co.uk/ and they have a distance learning course.

    You can do a BA in Horology at Birmingham University: https://www.bcu.ac.uk/courses/horology-ba-hons-2019-20

    And finally there's the British School of Watchmaking who are the only place in the UK that offer the Swiss WOSTEP certification: https://www.britishschoolofwatchmaking.co.uk/

    If you're interested in that sort of thing I'd recommend:

    https://smile.amazon.co.uk/Watchmaking-George-Daniels/dp/0856677043/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1540928011&sr=8-1&keywords=george+daniels+watchmaking

    And:

    https://smile.amazon.co.uk/Horology-Charles-Andre-Reymondin-Jeanneret-Pelaratti/dp/2940025126/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1540928055&sr=8-1&keywords=Theory+of+Horology

    For some serious watch/clock pron:

    https://smile.amazon.co.uk/Watches-Cecil-Clutton/dp/0856670588/ref=smi_www_rco2_go_smi_g7045452205?_encoding=UTF8&%2AVersion%2A=1&%2Aentries%2A=0&ie=UTF8

    https://www.amazon.co.uk/Art-Breguet-George-Daniels/dp/0856670049/ref=la_B001KIKTWA_1_3?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1540928184&sr=1-3

    George Daniels is a thoroughly interesting man though sadly no more.  I've often wondered if he was an Aspie.  His legacy lives on in his sort of "accidental prodigy" Roger Smith - https://www.rwsmithwatches.com/.  The SO and I went to see Roger's Great Britain watch when it was available for viewing in London: https://www.rwsmithwatches.com/watches/great-britain/ and much drooling ensued.  Probably never be able to afford one, but if money was no object I'd be happy to wait however long it took for Roger to knock me up something :-).

     > When we're talking Chinese knock-offs, you mean Seagull, not Selita! The Selita is pretty good. 

    I don't know who manufactured the Chinese ones we were using - they were completely unbranded.  They were an ETA 6497 copy and I also ordered an ETA 6497 (ETA were not the original designer/manufacturer). The ETA was superb to learn on.  We had a tray of the Chinese movements and as a class we spent a lot of time over the year going through all the movements trying to cobble together a whole movement each that actually worked :-/.  We were basically learning to do the Haynes manual complete strip-down and rebuild and then casing them plus we also looked at some older type pocket watches etc.

  • All mechanical movements "tick" - it's just a case of how noisy it is.  When you're setting a watch to rate the watch timing machine works by using a microphone to record the movement noise, and you adjust the rate of the watch by changing various things to get the different sounds the movement makes to occur at the right frequencies.

    I know that all movements tick, but with a higher beat rate, it's not noticably audible to me. I mean the 3600 BPH, tick. It irritates the life out of me, lol. I use Audacity and a microphone to regulate. It's very precise, and Audacity is free. I own quite a few decent microphones for recording music. It works just as good as a timegrapher. I always keep to the reccomended BPH for the piece though. Have you ever regulated a watch to run at a totally different beat rate? Say 28800 BPH to run at a 21600 BPH? I'd imagine the wheels need to be changed to a different ratio. 

    For every day wear I prefer a nice simple face.  I  like the face style of the early "field watches" and "fligers" too, but I'd want a sapphire crystal in the back so I could watch them working :-).

    Yeah, I'm that type of guy too! I'm not even that keen on a day function, sometimes a date is a bit unnecessary too. I like the Hamilton Khaki Field mechanical that was recently released. No date, and that faux old radium feel is really nice. ETA movement but my main gripe about ETA's, isn't a factor because they actually harden the crown wheel. Sinn is a brand that has some nice display backs. Hamilton Khaki King is one other watch that would spring straight to mind. I see display backs as a potential weakness. I got rid of my Hammy for a Seiko Alpinist. The 6R15 is a movement I like, plus the 20 ATM water resistance appealed to me. It's a "marmite watch", but I've found it much more practical. Archimede and Aristo make some nice stuff with display backs. Sapphire crystal of course! I don't know why Seiko palm Hardlex off on the rest of the world, but manage to use Sapphire in a lot of JDM models.

    The thing is, for a "Swiss" watch, how much the watch costs bears very little resemblance to what movement it has in it.

    I've seen a few "designed by ...." boutique "jewellers" watches, that cost over 20k with 2824-2 movements.

    And many of the "Swiss watches" have ETA movements.

    I've seen German and British watches with Selitas and ETA's. The German brands such as Sinn, do put some of their own touches in and harden stuff. I'm a guy who does give his auto a "bump" sometimes by winding. Stock ETA's really don't like winding. I'm actually quite enamoured with the Miyota 9015, because it loves to be wound. Ugly as *** but that is a nice thing.

     The ETA movements often go back to the earlier manufacturers who were  bought up by the Swatch group on the cheap when the Swiss watch industry was taking a battering from Japanese etc. Quartz and digital watches.

    Lol, yeah, the "Quartz crisis" worked out well for Swatch. The scooped up some prestigious brands!

    I spent a year doing a watchmaking course part-time, and compared to Chinese knock-off versions of an ETA movement the ETA version was light years better quality and far easier to work with!

    That's something I'd like to do myself. Must have been great! When we're talking Chinese knock-offs, you mean Seagull, not Selita! The Selita is pretty good. The SW300's especially. I would say that though Sinn use them, and I'm a big Sinn fan. Some say over-engineered but I've never had to de-mag a Sinn, never had the case fog, and never had a scratch on one!

    I'm quite partial to some of the IWC, CWC, Laco watches.

    You are a man of taste! IWC love the anti-magnetic stuff. Soft iron shell, anti-mag "faraday cage", CWC are British history, and Laco make some wonderfully simple but classy designs. I like Sinn, Hanhart, JDM Seiko, and there's a Canadian microbrand called Halios I like, original designs, robust, and they don't make too many of a piece.

Reply
  • All mechanical movements "tick" - it's just a case of how noisy it is.  When you're setting a watch to rate the watch timing machine works by using a microphone to record the movement noise, and you adjust the rate of the watch by changing various things to get the different sounds the movement makes to occur at the right frequencies.

    I know that all movements tick, but with a higher beat rate, it's not noticably audible to me. I mean the 3600 BPH, tick. It irritates the life out of me, lol. I use Audacity and a microphone to regulate. It's very precise, and Audacity is free. I own quite a few decent microphones for recording music. It works just as good as a timegrapher. I always keep to the reccomended BPH for the piece though. Have you ever regulated a watch to run at a totally different beat rate? Say 28800 BPH to run at a 21600 BPH? I'd imagine the wheels need to be changed to a different ratio. 

    For every day wear I prefer a nice simple face.  I  like the face style of the early "field watches" and "fligers" too, but I'd want a sapphire crystal in the back so I could watch them working :-).

    Yeah, I'm that type of guy too! I'm not even that keen on a day function, sometimes a date is a bit unnecessary too. I like the Hamilton Khaki Field mechanical that was recently released. No date, and that faux old radium feel is really nice. ETA movement but my main gripe about ETA's, isn't a factor because they actually harden the crown wheel. Sinn is a brand that has some nice display backs. Hamilton Khaki King is one other watch that would spring straight to mind. I see display backs as a potential weakness. I got rid of my Hammy for a Seiko Alpinist. The 6R15 is a movement I like, plus the 20 ATM water resistance appealed to me. It's a "marmite watch", but I've found it much more practical. Archimede and Aristo make some nice stuff with display backs. Sapphire crystal of course! I don't know why Seiko palm Hardlex off on the rest of the world, but manage to use Sapphire in a lot of JDM models.

    The thing is, for a "Swiss" watch, how much the watch costs bears very little resemblance to what movement it has in it.

    I've seen a few "designed by ...." boutique "jewellers" watches, that cost over 20k with 2824-2 movements.

    And many of the "Swiss watches" have ETA movements.

    I've seen German and British watches with Selitas and ETA's. The German brands such as Sinn, do put some of their own touches in and harden stuff. I'm a guy who does give his auto a "bump" sometimes by winding. Stock ETA's really don't like winding. I'm actually quite enamoured with the Miyota 9015, because it loves to be wound. Ugly as *** but that is a nice thing.

     The ETA movements often go back to the earlier manufacturers who were  bought up by the Swatch group on the cheap when the Swiss watch industry was taking a battering from Japanese etc. Quartz and digital watches.

    Lol, yeah, the "Quartz crisis" worked out well for Swatch. The scooped up some prestigious brands!

    I spent a year doing a watchmaking course part-time, and compared to Chinese knock-off versions of an ETA movement the ETA version was light years better quality and far easier to work with!

    That's something I'd like to do myself. Must have been great! When we're talking Chinese knock-offs, you mean Seagull, not Selita! The Selita is pretty good. The SW300's especially. I would say that though Sinn use them, and I'm a big Sinn fan. Some say over-engineered but I've never had to de-mag a Sinn, never had the case fog, and never had a scratch on one!

    I'm quite partial to some of the IWC, CWC, Laco watches.

    You are a man of taste! IWC love the anti-magnetic stuff. Soft iron shell, anti-mag "faraday cage", CWC are British history, and Laco make some wonderfully simple but classy designs. I like Sinn, Hanhart, JDM Seiko, and there's a Canadian microbrand called Halios I like, original designs, robust, and they don't make too many of a piece.

Children
  • Yeah, it did spring to mind. It could be a managable way of life. I gave up long ago about money, and I think that a modest living inside something I actually care about, plus can cope with is the way forward.

    That would be ideal, I'd imagine fixing Railmasters all day woukdn't be too sloppy!

  • Former Member
    Former Member in reply to Cloudy Mountains

    For someone with ASD, I don't think it's not a bad choice of career if you can live on the money.  Much of the time will be spent at the bench working on your own.  The guys I spoke to at the BHI said it was something you did because you loved it rather than for the money per-se.

    One of the guys at EFHC who had a few more years experience than me, plus he worked in the jewellery industry already IIRC, got sponsored by Omega I think to go to the British School of Watchmaking.

  • Thanks for the links Windscale. When or if my situation improves, it's something I've considered persuing. I've still got time, and a bit of knowledge beforehand, so it's certainly an option. I'd like to do high-end repairs, more than anything. I like restoring stuff.

    Looking at those Amazon links I see Breguet. Swatch swallowed that up too. I like pocket watches, but I'd only buy one as a collection piece. I'd like one of those really old Glashütte pocket watches. Germany had a pretty rich history of horology, predating the Swiss in a lot of aspects. The Nazi's and the Communists both destroyed Glashütte's industry, but since the wall fell, they have gone straight back to doing what they do best. It amazes me how what is essentially a village, has so many great watchmakers.

    Yeah, I like the Series Two probably best out of the Roger Smith pieces. It's great that Smith has started using tourbillons too, but that makes them more unobtainable, we can still look and drool though. Breguet has a lot to answer for, the invention of the tourbillon, and it's current surge in popularity puts some models way out of reach!

    I can't imagine they woukd have been Seagulls. Mind you I have seen a few nice models from Seagull. The 6497 was Unitas originally, but got sucked up into ETA. Nice movement to be looking at! Panerai have made some nice personal touches to the 6497, although it bumps up the price, and Panerai being on the dial does too! I find Panerai's designs a little brash and large. The largest watch I own is a 43mm case and that's because it's a shell case. I usually go around the 38mm to 40mm range. You've got me thinking about doing something like you did, it sounds pretty cool, and it could lead somewhere. 

  • Former Member
    Former Member in reply to Cloudy Mountains

    Have you ever regulated a watch to run at a totally different beat rate? Say 28800 BPH to run at a 21600 BPH? I'd imagine the wheels need to be changed to a different ratio. 

    Yes you're right, you'd have to redesign the going train to work at the different beat rate.  How much you'd have to change would depend on exactly what beat you were changing it to.

     I like the Hamilton Khaki Field mechanical that was recently released

    Yes I've looked at one of the Hamilton Khaki field watches that I quite liked but I don't recall what model it was.

    That's something I'd like to do myself. Must have been great!

    Yes, I'd like to do more, but I'm more interested in learning to design clocks/watches and then manufacture the parts.  Unfortunately we don't really have anywhere where we're currently living to house a load of machine tools :-(.  It's hard now in the UK to find anywhere to learn because the Horology industry has died so much.

    I went to Epping Forest Horology Centre: http://efhc.org.uk/wordpress/ and spent a year working with Lalit and others.

    The British Horological Institute run courses as well: https://bhi.co.uk/ and they have a distance learning course.

    You can do a BA in Horology at Birmingham University: https://www.bcu.ac.uk/courses/horology-ba-hons-2019-20

    And finally there's the British School of Watchmaking who are the only place in the UK that offer the Swiss WOSTEP certification: https://www.britishschoolofwatchmaking.co.uk/

    If you're interested in that sort of thing I'd recommend:

    https://smile.amazon.co.uk/Watchmaking-George-Daniels/dp/0856677043/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1540928011&sr=8-1&keywords=george+daniels+watchmaking

    And:

    https://smile.amazon.co.uk/Horology-Charles-Andre-Reymondin-Jeanneret-Pelaratti/dp/2940025126/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1540928055&sr=8-1&keywords=Theory+of+Horology

    For some serious watch/clock pron:

    https://smile.amazon.co.uk/Watches-Cecil-Clutton/dp/0856670588/ref=smi_www_rco2_go_smi_g7045452205?_encoding=UTF8&%2AVersion%2A=1&%2Aentries%2A=0&ie=UTF8

    https://www.amazon.co.uk/Art-Breguet-George-Daniels/dp/0856670049/ref=la_B001KIKTWA_1_3?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1540928184&sr=1-3

    George Daniels is a thoroughly interesting man though sadly no more.  I've often wondered if he was an Aspie.  His legacy lives on in his sort of "accidental prodigy" Roger Smith - https://www.rwsmithwatches.com/.  The SO and I went to see Roger's Great Britain watch when it was available for viewing in London: https://www.rwsmithwatches.com/watches/great-britain/ and much drooling ensued.  Probably never be able to afford one, but if money was no object I'd be happy to wait however long it took for Roger to knock me up something :-).

     > When we're talking Chinese knock-offs, you mean Seagull, not Selita! The Selita is pretty good. 

    I don't know who manufactured the Chinese ones we were using - they were completely unbranded.  They were an ETA 6497 copy and I also ordered an ETA 6497 (ETA were not the original designer/manufacturer). The ETA was superb to learn on.  We had a tray of the Chinese movements and as a class we spent a lot of time over the year going through all the movements trying to cobble together a whole movement each that actually worked :-/.  We were basically learning to do the Haynes manual complete strip-down and rebuild and then casing them plus we also looked at some older type pocket watches etc.