recent GP survey on stress not being an illness

When understanding why GPS might respond in the way they have to questions about the mental health of patients 
It might be worth considering how they themselves are feeling:
Key findings from international surveys and reports highlight:
  • High Stress Levels: In a survey of 10 high-income countries, 71% of UK GPs found their job "extremely" or "very stressful," the highest level among the nations surveyed.
  • Widespread Burnout: GPs are considered more vulnerable to burnout and work-related mental health problems than doctors in most other specialties. A BMA survey in 2024 found that nearly three-quarters of GP registrars (doctors in training) were experiencing burnout and stress.
  • Impact on Workforce: The unsustainable pressure and stress have led to many GPs reducing their hours, considering leaving their jobs altogether, or leaving the profession early, contributing to workforce shortages.
  • Workload as a Key Factor: The main source of stress is consistently identified as heavy workload, time pressure, and a large administrative burden, often compounded by staffing gaps and insufficient resources.
  • Organizational Culture: Lack of collegial support and unhealthy practice cultures (e.g., bullying) are also significant sources of distress, while strong team support is a key protective factor for individual well-being. 

So what I'm saying is that with GPs mostly living with extreme stress as part of their daily life (until they succumb to it themselves... )  it's hardly unlikely they think being stressed is not an illness.

Thoughts good people?

Parents
  • Already some interesting thoughts by others on this. The training for GPs takes a long time so those who have qualified have already coped with a lot more stress than others. Something I was wondering was how autistic GPs manage stress.

    For older people, they have often coped for a long while growing up in a society that was quite negative about mental health. Perhaps as there have been some changes, people are more likely to admit to it. Younger people have grown up in a very different society, but one that is a lot more isolating. Not only have they had the pandemic, but also a world where a lot is done online, so less mixing with others who might help or having exercise that could help with mental health. 

  • Something I was wondering was how autistic GPs manage stress.

    I don't think autists would be able to sustain a career as a GP. There are too many stressers of core autistic issues for them.

    Think about:

    High pressure medical training of 10+ years (5 years of medical school, followed by 2 years of foundation training, and an additional 3 to 8 years of specialty training, depending on the chosen field).

    Then you have the lack of routine, whether the very long days of hospital based training / specialisation or even the day work of constant 15 minute or less slots per patient.

    You have to be constantly dealing with patients, many of who are in a highly stressed state, so social skills will be pushed to the max.

    Sounds can be a challenge too as some patients are so loud, kids crying, patients shouting etc.

    Smells - ugh, no thanks!

    Etc.

    I honestly doubt any autist could stay the course to be a GP, and if they did then they are a crash waiting to happen.

  • I honestly doubt any autist could stay the course to be a GP, and if they did then they are a crash waiting to happen

    I wouldn’t think that all autistic GPs would agree with you.

    According to this journal, “Difficulties faced by autistic doctors, in our experience, rarely relate to patient care”. 
    https://bjgp.org/content/71/708/294

  • It is worthwhile noting the the article says we do not yet have prevalence rates for autistic doctors and the responses they got would be hard to make statistically meaningful conclusions from due to confirmational bias. 

    Exactly!

  • "twice exceptional" springs to mind 

  • thanks for the link to the evidence  

  • I wouldn’t think that all autistic GPs would agree with you.

    If they are able to sustain working in this field then they must be exceptional people indeed to not be overwhelmed by all the stressers present.

    It is worthwhile noting the the article says we do not yet have prevalence rates for autistic doctors and the responses they got would be hard to make statistically meaningful conclusions from due to confirmational bias. 

Reply
  • I wouldn’t think that all autistic GPs would agree with you.

    If they are able to sustain working in this field then they must be exceptional people indeed to not be overwhelmed by all the stressers present.

    It is worthwhile noting the the article says we do not yet have prevalence rates for autistic doctors and the responses they got would be hard to make statistically meaningful conclusions from due to confirmational bias. 

Children