• Replies 7 replies
  • Subscribers 29 subscribers
  • Views 369 views
  • Users 0 members are here
Options
Related
Hints and tips
  • To quote someone's message, first select/highlight the relevant text, and then use the Quote button that appears
  • To "mention" someone, type @ followed by the start of the forum name, and choose from the list; that person will get a notification of being mentioned

Another surgical scandal

TheCatWoman

Yet another health trust is having to conduct enquiries after it was found that a surgeon who is still employed by them but no longer opperating carried out unnessercary mastectomies. In this case it was complicated by the trust sending women to a private clinic which this surgeon owned and ran, not only was there a clear conflict of interest, but how can this sort of things be undetected for so long? I know the only difference between god and a consultant is that god dosen't think he can practice medicine, but the arrogance and lack of care towards women is shocking. 

Another thing, whilst you do hear of people being opperated on wrongly, does it seems to be overwhelmingly women who are mutilated by the medical profession? 

Parents
  • TheCatWoman said:
    I know the only difference between god and a consultant is that god dosen't think he can practice medicine

    Lol I’ve got a differing, less flattering opinion about god, but I’ll save that comment for another day.

    This is weird though. Like, why mastectomies in particular? Did he not specialize in any other type of surgery? ‘Cause yeah, if he was only specialized in mastectomies, that may partially answer your question as to why women in particular were targeted. Otherwise, I don’t know? I mean, I’d think this kind of scandal would be caused due to greedy intentions rather than a sick, sadistic desire to mutilate women, but because of the nature of the procedure it really makes you wonder…

Reply
  • TheCatWoman said:
    I know the only difference between god and a consultant is that god dosen't think he can practice medicine

    Lol I’ve got a differing, less flattering opinion about god, but I’ll save that comment for another day.

    This is weird though. Like, why mastectomies in particular? Did he not specialize in any other type of surgery? ‘Cause yeah, if he was only specialized in mastectomies, that may partially answer your question as to why women in particular were targeted. Otherwise, I don’t know? I mean, I’d think this kind of scandal would be caused due to greedy intentions rather than a sick, sadistic desire to mutilate women, but because of the nature of the procedure it really makes you wonder…

Children
  • in reply to profdanger

    It dosen't just happen in the private sector, theres been plenty in the NHS too, not just mastectomies, but hystorectomies and botched ones too that have left women incontinent, sometimes doubly so.

    We keep having these scandals and I really don't think its all about money, we're told lessons will be learned and we've been hearing this for years. I think theres still quite a lot of sexism in medicine, a lot of men choose to be gynaecologists and specialise in women's cancers and I wonder why? Obviously some will go into those fields with the best intentions, having family members who have suffered and wanting to be part of the solution instead of the problem. But, it also gives a lot of control over womens bodies and I don't think we should seperate doctors from any other section of society that want to control women and their bodies, its the ultimate cohersive control, tell a woman she has cancer and needs life saving surgery, who's not going to agree? How when you have such a diagnosis do you ask the right questions, let alone ask for a second opinion?

    I also wonder what the official and public response would be if female surgeons mutilated male patients in a similar way? 

  • in reply to profdanger
    profdanger said:
    I mean, I’d think this kind of scandal would be caused due to greedy intentions rather than a sick, sadistic desire to mutilate women, but because of the nature of the procedure it really makes you wonder…

    There is some info here.

    There was a financial incentive. 

    www.bbc.co.uk/.../c9qrn3y72dxo