Low sibilance TV

Hi.  I was diagnosed with Asperger’s about five years ago when I developed (among many other things!) as intense dislike of sibilance.

When I have to use a TV, I have been dealing with this by turning the treble control to minimum on our fairly old TV.  When my wife and I stay away from home I have noticed that hotel TV’s have huge levels of sibilance, probably as they are newer than our TV.

My wife wants to get a new TV in the sales and I am dreading it as I anticipate having to leave the room each time she wants to use it due to the awful sound.  It’s difficult to discuss with her as I get told to ‘deal with it’ and usually an argument develops.

Has anyone else with this problem found any solutions and can anyone suggest a make/model of TV with low levels of sibilance?

Many thanks in anticipation.

Parents
  • Thanks for the replies.  We ended-up with a Sony KDL48W705CBU as the (Limited) reviews I managed to find said the sound was not that bad.

    I have spent an hour or so playing with the settings, and despite turning the equaliser to minimum at all frequencies above 200Hz there does not seem much else I can do to reduce the sibilance.

    This is not a sound quality issue -  It seems to me that the ‘better’ quality sound systems produce more of the higher frequencies and so more sibilance.

    I don’t know why TV sound engineers don’t use de-essers as a matter of course. It’s a shame you can’t buy one that will work on the composite audio produced by a TV rather than needing to work on the speech component alone as this would solve my problem.

    I don’t really care if it is mono, stereo or surround.  If there were old fashioned hisses, crackles and pops that would also be OK.   I just want to minimise the sibilance. 

    I have tried time and again to design something that will remove sibilance from composite audio, but all I manage to do is remove the high frequencies altogether and so you can’t make out what is being said.  I think DSP is required with a very fast processor to actively seek out the sibilant points and remove only them and not the high frequencies, but although I am an electronic engineer, my programming abilities are too limited to attempt this type of project.

    I guess the next step is to go around the shops listening to sound bars as you have advised – The potential problem here is that the sound bar will only reproduce (To varying qualities) what it is input from the TV.  As I won’t have my TV with me it will be difficult to assess the sibilant performance.

    I guess I can’t make things any worse!

    Sorry if I sound an ungrateful complainer, I really do appreciate the replies and will let you know what happens.

    Thanks.

Reply
  • Thanks for the replies.  We ended-up with a Sony KDL48W705CBU as the (Limited) reviews I managed to find said the sound was not that bad.

    I have spent an hour or so playing with the settings, and despite turning the equaliser to minimum at all frequencies above 200Hz there does not seem much else I can do to reduce the sibilance.

    This is not a sound quality issue -  It seems to me that the ‘better’ quality sound systems produce more of the higher frequencies and so more sibilance.

    I don’t know why TV sound engineers don’t use de-essers as a matter of course. It’s a shame you can’t buy one that will work on the composite audio produced by a TV rather than needing to work on the speech component alone as this would solve my problem.

    I don’t really care if it is mono, stereo or surround.  If there were old fashioned hisses, crackles and pops that would also be OK.   I just want to minimise the sibilance. 

    I have tried time and again to design something that will remove sibilance from composite audio, but all I manage to do is remove the high frequencies altogether and so you can’t make out what is being said.  I think DSP is required with a very fast processor to actively seek out the sibilant points and remove only them and not the high frequencies, but although I am an electronic engineer, my programming abilities are too limited to attempt this type of project.

    I guess the next step is to go around the shops listening to sound bars as you have advised – The potential problem here is that the sound bar will only reproduce (To varying qualities) what it is input from the TV.  As I won’t have my TV with me it will be difficult to assess the sibilant performance.

    I guess I can’t make things any worse!

    Sorry if I sound an ungrateful complainer, I really do appreciate the replies and will let you know what happens.

    Thanks.

Children
No Data