I've recently discovered the joy (and fear) of horror games! I really like the tense, heavy atmospheres, the storytelling, and while the jumpscares still get me, they still add to the amtosphere!
I'm currently playing Resident Evil 3 and Five Nights at Freddy's: Security Breach RUIN. But the scariest game I've played so far is Five Nights at Freddy's VR: Help Wanted! It feels real! TOO real!!