Do you appreciate "Signposting" or would you rather a personal response

How do you feel when someone responds to a question by pointing you to another resource or piece of information instead of giving a direct answer? Do you find it helpful, dismissive, or something else entirely?

Parents
  • personally I find signposting a bit of a cop out in that it loses the personal qualities of a reply. If a question is asked I try to relate to that and answer in my honest way. I will sometimes try to signpost at the end of a reply if I think it is of benefit.

    This is not a criticism of others but I do find that there seems to be a constant screed of signposting in most replies in the threads. It is almost as if all human discourse has been replaced by the race to see who can signpost first. This forum is supposed to be a discussion board but sometimes can resemble a website help page.

    Keep up the conversations rather than the signposts. 

Reply
  • personally I find signposting a bit of a cop out in that it loses the personal qualities of a reply. If a question is asked I try to relate to that and answer in my honest way. I will sometimes try to signpost at the end of a reply if I think it is of benefit.

    This is not a criticism of others but I do find that there seems to be a constant screed of signposting in most replies in the threads. It is almost as if all human discourse has been replaced by the race to see who can signpost first. This forum is supposed to be a discussion board but sometimes can resemble a website help page.

    Keep up the conversations rather than the signposts. 

Children