What was so different about Roman and Post Roman Britain?

It does seem to have been very different, for one thing both Latin and whatever variant of Celtic was spoken disapeared to be replaced by English.

Britain seems to have reverted to Pre-Roman polities and tribal areas, some Romanitas remained, some cities were still lived in, mostly those further West, but they were in decline long before the collapse of the Western Roman Empire and the villa culture almost disapears over night.

Despite what many of us were taught at school and probably many still are taught, there was no mass Anglo-Saxon military take over and population replacement. Studies of DNA and stable isotope analysis show that most people were the same as were here before the Romans came, although it does depend on area, there are many around places such as Vindolanda on Hadrians wall that show mixed parentage, where presumably soldiers had local families.

Nobody knows what actually happened, fascinating eh? Any ideas, anyone?

Parents
  • That's interesting. I don't really remember learning about the Roman Empire, or perhaps I was taught it but didn't take it in or forgot it, and I remember hearing the term "Anglo Saxon" but couldn't recall anything about that period either (I really didn't take in information in school that was taught "at us")

    I wondered how the language changed to English so I did a quick search and discovered that the English language has its roots in 5th century Germany & Denmark, from where the Anglian, Saxon & Jute tribes came. You probably already know that Catwoman, but it might be interesting to anyone else reading the thread. Here's a link to the article I found about it:

    https://www.bbc.com/culture/article/20190118-how-migration-formed-the-english-language

    There are a couple of open learn courses I'm thinking of taking that might be relevant to this and if so I'll post what I learn. One is an introduction to the classical world (ancient Greeks & Romans) and another is A short introduction to the English language, which starts in 449 AD.

  • Part of the Anglo-Saxon poem 'The Battle of Brunanburh'.

    "Engle and Seaxe up becoman,
    ofer brad brimu Brytene sohtan,
    wlance wigsmiþas, Wealas ofercoman,
    eorlas arhwate eard begeatan."

    Angle and Saxon came up

    Over the [sea's] broad brim, seeking Britain

    Wise war-smiths, overcoming the Welsh

    Noble warriors, they took the land.

Reply
  • Part of the Anglo-Saxon poem 'The Battle of Brunanburh'.

    "Engle and Seaxe up becoman,
    ofer brad brimu Brytene sohtan,
    wlance wigsmiþas, Wealas ofercoman,
    eorlas arhwate eard begeatan."

    Angle and Saxon came up

    Over the [sea's] broad brim, seeking Britain

    Wise war-smiths, overcoming the Welsh

    Noble warriors, they took the land.

Children
No Data