What was so different about Roman and Post Roman Britain?

It does seem to have been very different, for one thing both Latin and whatever variant of Celtic was spoken disapeared to be replaced by English.

Britain seems to have reverted to Pre-Roman polities and tribal areas, some Romanitas remained, some cities were still lived in, mostly those further West, but they were in decline long before the collapse of the Western Roman Empire and the villa culture almost disapears over night.

Despite what many of us were taught at school and probably many still are taught, there was no mass Anglo-Saxon military take over and population replacement. Studies of DNA and stable isotope analysis show that most people were the same as were here before the Romans came, although it does depend on area, there are many around places such as Vindolanda on Hadrians wall that show mixed parentage, where presumably soldiers had local families.

Nobody knows what actually happened, fascinating eh? Any ideas, anyone?

Parents
  • The Picts of Alba were never conquered. It is such a pity that they never had the written word it would have been so good to actually get a different viewpoint than that of the Romans.

    Maybe it is why we Scots have such an independent streak. Unconquered genes maybe?

Reply
  • The Picts of Alba were never conquered. It is such a pity that they never had the written word it would have been so good to actually get a different viewpoint than that of the Romans.

    Maybe it is why we Scots have such an independent streak. Unconquered genes maybe?

Children
  • The Picts were conquered, or at least absorbed and their language and culture suppressed, by the Dal Riada Scots of the Argyll area, who were originally Irish, from north-east Ulster. For a time, the McAlpin dynasty ruled both the Argyll area and also part of Ulster. This is why the Irish language and Scots Gaelic are so similar, it was imported from Ireland. The kingdom of Scotland was the creation of the McAlpin kings from the Dal Riada Irish, the Picts, the 'Welsh' (really northern Britons, speaking Cumbric a relative of Early Welsh) of Strathclyde, the Norse-Gaels of Galloway and the English (Northumbrians) of Lothian. Lothian was ceded by the king of England to the Scots in 1018.

  • I doubt it Mr T as so many Scots were actually Irish who created the Kingdom of Dalriata, Scotland was conquered almost up to Edinbrught by the Northumbrian Anglo-Saxons and the Vikings took over much of the Highlandds and Islands.

    But I agree its a shame that we know so little about the Picts and about the people who were living in Scotland before the Romans came.