Why everything you know about autism is wrong!

I found this YouTube clip while being unable to sleep!

https://m.youtube.com/watch?feature=youtu.be&v=A1AUdaH-EPM

What does everyone think of what she has to say?

Parents
  • She explains the social vs medical models of disability very well. I can certainly relate,  as Plastic said, to the fact that most of the problems I've ever faced are caused by interacting with more typical people, and I certainly communicate much less anxiously and with lower stress (even enjoyment) with autistic people than others.

    However, I wonder how far the "paradigm shift" can be regarded as absolute? For instance, I have some difficulties that probably trace to my autism, and which don't involve other people or society generally. The examples are quite trivial (e.g. I hate touching emery paper or dry wooden spoons, I believe I have aphantasia and I definitely have alexithymia) but I can't say that these would disappear if people would accommodate me better.

    On balance though, I very much agree that I feel simply different rather than faulty, and wish that I had not had five decades of thinking I was out of step, weird, depressed, misanthropic, unsociable, unlikable, and underachieving in things that others seem to do with ease (I went all the way academically, but I found this easy so I tend not to count it as success).

    So on balance, I support the Neurodiversity paradigm, but I'm wary of associating too much with the Neurodiversity movement *only* because there are those who attack it and I don't wish to be attacked. [Edit - actually, on reflection, it's more than this. See my reply to Flint below]

Reply
  • She explains the social vs medical models of disability very well. I can certainly relate,  as Plastic said, to the fact that most of the problems I've ever faced are caused by interacting with more typical people, and I certainly communicate much less anxiously and with lower stress (even enjoyment) with autistic people than others.

    However, I wonder how far the "paradigm shift" can be regarded as absolute? For instance, I have some difficulties that probably trace to my autism, and which don't involve other people or society generally. The examples are quite trivial (e.g. I hate touching emery paper or dry wooden spoons, I believe I have aphantasia and I definitely have alexithymia) but I can't say that these would disappear if people would accommodate me better.

    On balance though, I very much agree that I feel simply different rather than faulty, and wish that I had not had five decades of thinking I was out of step, weird, depressed, misanthropic, unsociable, unlikable, and underachieving in things that others seem to do with ease (I went all the way academically, but I found this easy so I tend not to count it as success).

    So on balance, I support the Neurodiversity paradigm, but I'm wary of associating too much with the Neurodiversity movement *only* because there are those who attack it and I don't wish to be attacked. [Edit - actually, on reflection, it's more than this. See my reply to Flint below]

Children