Forum CONTENTS (non techy) - if we could design it ourselves, what would it look like?

Disclaimer: I am an aspie, I am not from the NAS.

In the spirit of self advocacy, having a say and peer to peer support, there were discussions of the things that would help autistic adults in a really helpful way.

https://community.autism.org.uk/f/adults-on-the-autistic-spectrum/15461/if-we-could-design-it-ourselves-what-would-as-services-look-like

One of the frequently mentioned area was the improvement of the online forum, its CONTENT, POSSIBILITIES, and STRUCTURE

This is not a discussion about technology, although it is welcome and helpful too. What information, how organised, which topics?

Hence, this thread is the discussion, like a consultation of what would be helpful and how it could look like, how it could be done. Completely informal and all comments are welcome.

This is an attempt at collaborative working,

so tell if there is anything in the written below that you would like to add, remove, put a different emphasis on.

 Some of the thoughts so far:

An online forum

  1. Lay out : there needs to be a clear, concise area where people can go to be the single point of access to all things wrt our condition (diagnosed and undiagnosed) to help rather than having to search for the right/wrong keyword on the internet/forums.  
  2. Resources, summarised as tailored help to navigate the law, health, my mental health and dealing with service providers. 
  3. Pinned threads, thematic guest presentations, interactive Q&As
  4. 1:1 online advice functionality or forum advice, private group discussion functionality
  5. People could volunteer to lead on this or that support to other members, peer to peer support
  6. Virtual social groups by topics and interests, like biking, 
  7. Improved functionality, experience and security

I will explain a bit point by point

  1. Lay out.

Maybe there should be a front page with the structure of the forum and clear sign posting

There should be a resource and knowledge area where one can access some key documents, concise articles and resources without going into discussion threads. The question will be how is it different to current NAS website? Maybe it should link to the NAS pages but also have additional resources, the key point it would serve as a sign posting tree (sorry I hope it makes sense) with some comments maybe.

This resource area could be fragmented by forum, or topic, liked to the forum landing page or it could be a ‘solid’ separate resource section which links back to the forum. [discuss]

The entry to resource area could be a paragraph with the links to the resource area landing page on top of forums or a totally separate resource and sign posting area, a separate landing page linked to the front page from where there would be branches into topics with resources, links to the forums, but not showing forum threads on that page [DISCUSS]

 I  think it would be good if forums had subtopic forums, so one could go and look at a particular topic of interest, for example the diagnosis, inside the adults forum. [just think in terms of layout structure)

 I think it would be easier if within the thread messages appeared in chronological order rather than multiple sub threads, but that’s me.

  1. Resources, summarised as tailored help to navigate the law, health, my mental health and dealing with service providers

Which topics and resources? How different to what is now?

  • Diagnosis pathways
  • Introductory crash course for newly diagnosed/referred
  • Key concepts, research, discussions
  • Law, employment, benefits, health, dealing with providers, relationships, education and SEN

SUGGESTIONS?

3. Pinned threads, thematic guest presentations, interactive Q&As

Would it be interesting to have some specific very good threads pinned on top of the topic forum as a resource?

Would it be good to have a guest speakers style things, get a list of very targeted questions, get a professional to to write a little blog, addressing some of the questions, it would be interesting if it would go beyond generic basics, some really targeted, specific aspects that autistic people struggle with. Whom would you invite?

Interactive Q&A like get questions, and having a live discussion thread ? Whom would you invite?

 4. 1:1 online advice functionality or forum advice, private group discussion functionality

More than talking 1:1 via PM with friends, this is about ‘requesting’ a 1:1 conversation as a peer to peer advice on a topic where more sensitive and private details could be discussed without being visible on the web. advice from a specific named poster or from someone with ‘expertise’. It should be clear this is just online advice forum, people don’t have ‘qualifications’ and can just share their experience and opinion. This is to be flagged clearly. We could define clear rules, does and don’ts.

The same private discussion I private thematic groups would be good as well. Here you could run a thread with a number of people <=20, which would not show on the forum, members only. Could limit/define which discussions are not on, in line with general rules or only have private group topics which are pre-authorised.

5. People could volunteer to lead on this or that topic to other members, peer to peer support

This is already the case, people share their experience on relevant threads

6. Virtual social groups by topics and interests, like biking

Would it be good to be able to find people with similar interests and talk to them or even meet up? 

7. Improved functionality, experience and security

I think messages displaying chronologically would be good…

Please share your thoughts, discuss this proposal

  • An online forum would be a great idea to help people with our condition. It would be a great resource to have all the information in one place, and it would be easier to find the right information. It would also be helpful to have pinned threads, thematic guest presentations, and interactive Q&As. It would help people to get the information they need and to learn from others who have different experiences. I suppose it's also important for any forum to have a nice design. I heard that guys from www.weareframework.co.uk/.../ can do a great job at a modest price. I totally support this idea!

  • Required options:

    ignore members

    block members.

  • I don't quite understand the purpose of this? 

    Anyway, I personally found it useful to be able to browse the contents of the forum before deciding if I want to join or not. I might not have signed up if I didn't have any information about how active it is, what topics were being discussed, and how polite people generally are on the forums. I think being able to spend some time viewing it before joining was really helpful. And I think making it public will also make it more accessible to people who might have social anxieties about joining forums to obtain information on autism. Having it public can also make more people aware of the forum and eventually join the forum, for example, if someone who has never heard of the forum was searching using key words on google, one of the posts here may pop up during the search. 

    I do not object to having a members-only subsection, if people would like to use that part of the forum to talk about more personal matters, or talk about things that has to due with functionality of the forum. 

  • I think it would be additionally nice if this forum that an *official* research page, where researchers can post about new studies recruiting participants. (They will need to provide proof that there are working in a university/research institute, give their university email address, the name of the principal investigator, be clear about the contents of the study, provide a participants' information sheet, and provide their research ethics approval number). 

  • in fact setting up a forum is not that hard and i already run my own server.

  • OK, check my thread on the linked post in the opening forum post, I will add some more thoughts here:-

    Layout

    • Make it easy to use/navigate on ALL devices (tablets/phones can be restricted viewing).
    • Layout of Forums could be improved with, dare I say, an improved structure to the five main topic areas to include another layer of sub-topics.
    • Artificial Intelligence to help collate "keywords" better for an improved search/linkability - even I do not know how to tag posts/articles.
    • Improved structure/layout to make access so much easier (I always think Keep it Simple with as few clicks/etc as possible).  This annoys me with some websites and the damn automated service when phoning companies/etc.

    Resources, etc

    • Fully agree with this to possible include Books, internet article links, research links, etc - like Wikipedia's use of links, See Also, References and Bibliography.
    • Need clear, concise Guidelines, Rules, etc that everyone understands.

    Pinned Threads, etc

    • With the right site layout then Pinned Threads would not be required (maybe some of the information could be consolidated into the appropriate articles that the thread/post covers).
    • Blogging, Presentations may be something useful to help communicate to the outside world on the conditions and could also include others (e.g. Stephen Fry with his Bipolar).
    • With the right design, layout, search and integration then Interactive Q&A may be overkill.  In fact the Forum does that up to a point anyway.

    1:1 Online Advice, etc

    • Setting up the right website/environment then the openness is there, PM/personal email conversations may be more useful for those of us that are of a certain level of competence/trustworthiness/ability on the site whilst basic PM would still be available to anyone with an account

    Volunteering

    • Those of us on here posting/replying are effective volunteers.
    • Peer to peer support could be useful with the right design (e.g. I tag myself with my knowledge, skills and experience that can be searchable by anyone with an account, etc).

    Improved Functionality, etc

    • It would be useful to have layers of security for sure, especially as we should not be talking about things to do with our job, employer, etc.
    • With the right tool design, the forums could be reduced to simple links to the knowledge articles.
    • Also with the right Profile page(s) layout then that could also act as our "Introduce Yourself" as well as other useful information on Diagnosis, Knowledge, Skills and Experience.

    Even though I am a techie, I am also someone who knows/understands the issues for non-techies.

  • Sorry i did not have the patience to read all of that. The current forum software needs abolishing and replacing with something sensible like the wrong planet forum. I have lost interest in this forum because it is so awful it's not worth my effort.

  • make searching much better, and also make it much easier to look back at your own posts

  • make the entire contents of the forums NON-public (ie threads cannot be viewed unless a member)