sherlock - an autistic Best Man's speech?

Is it just my lack of a sense of humour, but was the painful prolonged best man's speech simply characterisation of a contemporary Sherlock Holmes figure, or given the current imputation he is meant to portray autism, a rather inappropriate charicature?

Does anyone still identify with the new Sherlock?

  • I believe the Sherlock referred to in that quote is from the American series Elementary. Not helped by their use of Benedict Cumberbach's photo.  

  • longman said:
    One pyschiatrist is saying that there are a lot of adults being irresponsibly diagnosed because they have a few eccentricities, which bear no relation to the real condition.

    That alone gives cause for concern.  By any chance was this an NHS psychiatrist! Money Mouth

    As it would appear there is a deliberate attempt not to diagnose both children and adults with autism by the NHS (to avoid draining services and giving rise to benefits applications), comments such as this would fit.

    I think the chances of people being misdiagnosed with autism are extremely slim, all clinicians use the same diagnostic criteria.  No ethical clinician would risk the damage to their professional reputation for one.

    I think it more boils down to arrogant psychiatrists, with outdated and ridiculous views, believing that if someone can work or get married or do other things that a neurotypical can do, then there is no way they can be autistic.  They don't understand masking, or at what cost it is to the person.  How they may want to die from anxiety before they leave the house, how they may sit stimming and rocking away from the public eye, how they may panic when their post arrives, how they may meltdown because their day is disrupted.

    If anyone wants to know how it is being autistic, like I keep saying, try asking us.

  • There's a big debate about the current television adaptation of Sherlock (Benedict Cumberbach) at the moment, with psychologists and psychiatrists contributing (revealing a lot about their strange understanding of autism!).

    One pyschiatrist is saying that there are a lot of adults being irresponsibly diagnosed because they have a few eccentricities, which bear no relation to the real condition.

    NAS became part of this on 6th December, a NAS Ambassador (Robyn Stewart) in the Telegraph, arguing that the episode where Sherlock's brother arrives in New York, his response is apparently Aspergers.

    Conan Doyle, whether or not he believed in faries, never imagined Sherlock as he is now being portrayed.

    But I think it is dangerous to try to attach this characterisation of Sherlock to aspergers or autism, because it might be harmful to our best interests.

  • Sounds like a big hole - the reason I don't enjoy fiction - because all I do is sit there picking holes in it, you don't want to watch a movie with me ! Anyway the author believed in fairies. Some holes are just too big.

    Why didn't Frodo just get on one of those giant flying creatures and fly over mordor and drop the ring in ? Why didn't Harry Potter go back in time and stop Voldemort from killing his parents or just from being born ?